Studio Simonini

Scopo di quest'area è di raccogliere, in sintesi, i riferimenti tecnologici che sono alla base delle soluzioni allo studio. Per immagini e rapidi links, lo Studio Simonini indica le fonti considerate e monitorate, sperimentate ed utilizzate: possono essere spunto per discussioni all'interno dell'area Forum. Tutti i Marchi sono dei rispettivi Proprietari.

Large Language Models - Chats and Software engineering

In these days, I falled in a dispute with 'ChatGPT'*. Here a commented extract of the working session(s), with only typo adjusts. Contact Studio Simonini for more details.

* ChatGPT, AI-powered chatbot from OpenAI at openai.com/blog/chatgpt/ 

Me: In the following code, insert code in order to not execute the loop*. Please, insert the necessary code.

    PROGRAM stexample
      VAR
        x : BOOL;
        a : INT;
        b : INT;
      END_VAR
      a := 1; b := 3; x := TRUE;
      REPEAT
        IF a > b THEN
          b := 0;
          x := FALSE;
        ELSE
          a := a + 1
        END_IF;
      UNTIL x = FALSE;
      END_REPEAT;
    END_PROGRAM;

// * My comment: here and following the phrase "not execute the loop", for the "REPEAT-UNTIL" loop code, means "escape" as soon as possible the loop.

ChatGPT: To not execute the loop, you can simply set the value of x to FALSE before the REPEAT statement:

    PROGRAM stexample
      VAR..
      a := 1;
      b := 3;
      x := FALSE;  // Set x to FALSE to not execute the loop
      REPEAT
        IF a > b THEN
          b := 0;
          x := FALSE;
        ELSE
          a := a + 1
        END_IF;
      UNTIL x = FALSE;
      END_REPEAT;
    END_PROGRAM;

    Alternatively, you can also add a BREAK statement within the IF block to exit the loop early:

    PROGRAM stexample
      VAR..
      a := 1;
      b := 3;
      x := TRUE;
      REPEAT
        IF a > b THEN
          b := 0;
          BREAK;  // Exit the loop
        ELSE
          a := a + 1
        END_IF;
      UNTIL x = FALSE;
      END_REPEAT;
    END_PROGRAM;

// My comment: ChatGPT shows a good knowledge of ST programming code.

// ChatGPT: This code defines a program called "stexample" that contains a single variable called "x" of type BOOL (a Boolean variable that can hold the values "TRUE" or "FALSE"). The code sets the value of "x" to "TRUE", and then enters a loop that continuously sets the value of "x" to "FALSE" and checks if it is equal to "FALSE". Since "x" is always set to "FALSE" within the loop, the condition "x = FALSE" will always be true, and the loop will run indefinitely. This code does not perform any useful tasks and will run indefinitely, potentially causing the program to hang or crash. It is likely that this code is intended as an example or a placeholder, rather than a complete and functional program.

Me: why not to use a := a + b to avoid loop iterations?

// My comment: more in depth.. the "dispute"

ChatGPT: Using a := a + b will not necessarily avoid loop iterations, as it depends on the value of b and the condition being checked in the loop.

    For example, if b is a positive number and the loop is checking whether a is greater than some value, then adding b to a on each iteration will eventually cause the loop to terminate. However, if b is a negative number or the condition being checked is different, then this approach may not work as expected.

    In general, it is important to carefully consider the condition being checked in the loop and how the loop variables are being updated to ensure that the loop will terminate as intended.

Me: In this case, b = 3 and a = 1, so a+b > b in order to avoid loop. Correct ?

    No, that is not correct. In the code you provided, the IF statement is checking whether a > b, not whether a + b > b. Therefore, adding b to a on each iteration will not necessarily cause the loop to terminate.

    If you want to avoid executing the loop altogether, you can set the value of x to FALSE before the REPEAT statement, as I suggested in my previous response. Alternatively, you can add a BREAK statement within the IF block to exit the loop early if the condition being checked is met.

    It is also worth noting that the loop in the code you provided will eventually terminate, as the value of a is incremented on each iteration until it becomes greater than b. Once this happens, the value of x is set to FALSE, and the loop will terminate on the next iteration.

// My comment: not enough and more details by my side

Me: You are correct, my intention is to use instruction a := a + b before loop starts

ChatGPT: If your intention is to use the instruction a := a + b before the loop starts in order to avoid executing the loop,

    then you can simply place this instruction before the REPEAT statement and set the value of x to FALSE afterwards:

    PROGRAM stexample
      VAR..
      a := 1;
      b := 3;
      a := a + b;  // Add b to a before the loop starts
      x := FALSE;  // Set x to FALSE to not execute the loop
      REPEAT
        IF a > b THEN
          b := 0;
          x := FALSE;
        ELSE
          a := a + 1
        END_IF;
      UNTIL x = FALSE;
      END_REPEAT;
    END_PROGRAM;

    This will add b to a before the loop starts and then set the value of x to FALSE, which will cause the loop to be skipped entirely. Alternatively, you can also use a goto statement to jump past the loop:

    PROGRAM stexample
      VAR..
      a := 1;
      b := 3;
      a := a + b;  // Add b to a before the loop starts
      x := TRUE;
      goto skip_loop;  // Jump past the loop
      REPEAT
        IF a > b THEN
          b := 0;
          x := FALSE;
        ELSE
          a := a + 1
        END_IF;
      UNTIL x = FALSE;
      END_REPEAT;
      skip_loop:
    END_PROGRAM;

    Using a goto statement can be useful in certain situations, but it is generally considered to be a less readable and less maintainable approach compared to using a flag variable like x or using a BREAK statement to exit the loop early.

Me: Correct, but if i use "a:=a+b" is no longer necessary the statement "x := FALSE" for exit loop. Correct?

ChatGPT: If you are using the instruction a := a + b before the loop starts and you do not want the loop to be executed at all, then you can simply omit the x := FALSE statement and the loop will not be executed. For example:

        PROGRAM stexample
          VAR..
          a := 1;
          b := 3;
          a := a + b;  // Add b to a before the loop starts
          x := TRUE;  // Set x to TRUE to execute the loop
          REPEAT
            IF a > b THEN
              b := 0;
              x := FALSE;  // This statement is not necessary
            ELSE
              a := a + 1
            END_IF;
          UNTIL x = FALSE;
          END_REPEAT;
        END_PROGRAM;

    In this case, the value of a is incremented by b before the loop starts, and since the value of x is set to TRUE, the loop will be executed. However, since the condition a > b is already met, the IF block will be executed and the value of b will be set to 0. The value of x is then set to FALSE, but this is not necessary because the loop will already have terminated due to the UNTIL x = FALSE condition being met.

    * So, to answer your question, it is not necessary to set the value of x to FALSE in order to exit the loop if you are

    using the instruction a := a + b before the loop starts and you do not want the loop to be executed at all

    However, it is still important to carefully consider the condition being checked in the loop and how the loop variables    are being updated to ensure that the loop will behave as intended.

// * My comment: this is the point #

Me: Thanks.

ChatGPT: You're welcome! I'm glad I could help. If you have any further questions, don't hesitate to ask.

Progetti di Computer Vision e 'Machine Learning' *

Applicazioni 'Web-based' e 'in Cloud'

L'attenzione dello Studio Simonini al mondo 'Open Source' ed alla produttività 'Web based' si concretizza nella individuazione di una Suite di applicativi denominata ‘PerSol Suite’ composta da:
 - frame work CMS Drupal
 - stack applicativo XAMP (Apache, MySql e Php)
 - ambienti operativi Windows e Linux
 - server applicativo Apache (anche su Zend Server). Microservices e IoT
 

Ultima modifica: Gen-2017

Sicurezza e Cifratura

Lo Studio Simonini è da sempre attivamente coinvolto nella valutazione dell'impatto che le Tecnologie adottate hanno sui temi della Sicurezza Informatica.

Client Side Encryption Demo

Ultima modifica: Ott-2011

Mobile applications

Riferimenti

Android develop

Google phone e Wearable

Ultima modifica: Dic-2009
 

Risparmio energetico

La recente norma UNI EN 15232:2007, “Incidenza dell’Automazione, della regolazione e della Gestione Tecnica degli Edifici”, consente di valutare il risparmio energetico generato da un impianto di Building Automation (HBA) e più in generale dall’Automazione realizzata.
La riduzione dei consumi (e costi) energetici è un fattore strategico per il successo Aziendale. Accanto all’uso efficiente dell’energia (sicuramente sempre più importante), un uso "efficace delle energie" passa proprio per l'Automazione, la misura ed il "controllo" degli imianti (non solo industriali).

Ultima modifica: Feb-2009
 

IT e AUT: Ethernet industriale

Sempre più il modello "IT" entra nell'"eco-sistema" dell'Automazione Industriale portando modelli di soluzione interessanti. E' il caso dell'Ethernet industriale che, in varie forme, interpreta e re-interpreta la tecnologia Ethernet in ambiente di fabbrica. 

Ultima modifica: Feb-2009 
* Per maggiori dettagli si contatti direttamente lo Studio